Your Team Doesn't Read Your Strategy. They Read Your Budget.
The strategic plan says what you want. The budget says what you'll do.
On December 7, 2022, Southwest Airlines announced it was bringing back its quarterly dividend. Less than two weeks later, it cancelled nearly 17,000 flights and left about 2 million people stranded over the holidays.
Weather started it. The crew scheduling system turned it into a meltdown. And the people flying the planes saw it coming. The pilots' union had been warning about that scheduling technology for years. A month before Christmas, its president said the airline was one thunderstorm or one router failure away from a complete meltdown. The company later put the cost at nearly $1.2 billion.
The pilots never needed the strategy deck. They could see where the money went, and where it didn't.
You don't run an airline. But your team reads your budget the same way, and they believe it over anything on the strategy slide.
What You Call Resistance Is Your Team Reading the Budget
Owners say it all the time. We rolled out the new direction, and the team won't get behind it.
Look at what the team saw. The new direction was announced in January. The headcount went where it always goes. The old programs kept their money. The new initiative was told to "find a way." Your people didn't resist the strategy. They read the budget, and they read it correctly.
Your newest hire worked it out before her laptop arrived. On day one she heard the welcome speech: the new service line is the future. By day three she'd noticed that the new service line had one part-time person and a shared login, while the legacy account had four people and the best desks. By Friday she knew which speech was true. She never saw the strategic plan.
An unfunded priority does more damage than no priority at all. No priority leaves people waiting for direction. An unfunded one teaches them that leadership's word is cheap, and that lesson outlasts the plan it came from. Every plan after it starts at a discount.
Our growth formula shows where that cost lands:
Growth = [(Pipeline × Conversion × Team Capacity) × Traction] ÷ Drag
A funded priority, with people who believe in it, is traction. An unfunded one is drag. People spend hours on work the company won't back, wait on decisions that never come and rework plans that were never real. And drag divides everything else in the equation. Every priority announced and left unfunded takes something that should have multiplied growth and turns it into something that divides it.
Your Strategy Gets Set in the Spreadsheet
Most owners believe their strategy gets set at the off-site. The real decisions get made weeks later, in budget season, and often by someone who wasn't in the room.
In a lot of growing companies, the budget is built by the controller, the outside accountant or a capable finance lead working from last year's numbers. They do exactly what they were asked to do: start from what was spent, add a growth rate and make it balance. That's a sound way to build a budget. It's also a strategy, and it's last year's.
So most of the money is committed before anyone asks what it's for. The software seats nobody logs into. The agency retainer from two strategies ago. The trade show you attend because you always have. Each one was a decision once. Now it renews on its own, like a subscription nobody remembers signing up for. The company says it's heading somewhere new while paying, line by line, for where it used to go.
The owner who hands off the budget has handed off the strategy.
The plan can say anything it likes. The spreadsheet decides.
Taking it back starts with one question for every large line: would we buy this today if we weren't already paying for it? Spend Is Earned. argued that the pipeline should earn each new dollar before it's spent. The dollars already moving deserve the same test. A line earned three years ago has to keep earning its place, or it's funding a strategy the company already left. And if the pipeline number the budget rests on means something different to marketing, sales and finance, settle that first. Three Definitions Of Pipeline Is Two Too Many shows how.
The Even Cut Is a Decision Not to Decide
When margin gets tight, the familiar move is to ask every department for 10 percent. It looks fair, and that's its appeal. Nobody has to choose. Nobody has to tell a leader their program matters less.
An even cut is a leader declining to decide, dressed up as discipline. It says the priority you announced in January matters exactly as much as the tool nobody logs into. The people doing your most important work feel it first, because they were already stretched, and they learn what the new hire learned: the speech was talk.
Real margin control is a harder conversation about what the money is for. Protect what's tied to growth. Cut the habits. Keep the comforts you choose to keep, and call them comforts. It takes longer than a spreadsheet formula, and it's the only kind of cut that leaves the strategy standing.
Fewer Priorities, Said Out Loud
In Problem Solving For Capacity, Capability, Priority or Budget? we called priority the cheapest constraint to fix and the hardest to face, because it costs nothing but a decision. The budget is where that decision shows up, or doesn't.
A priority is real when three things are true:
There's money behind it,
There are people with time freed up to do the work, and
One person owns it.
Miss any one, and it's a wish your team has already learned to ignore.
A priority list longer than five is a list of things you won't say no to. Most leadership teams carry ten and fund three. We'd rather see three funded and seven taken off the list in public. Removing a priority feels like a loss, especially at the top, where every executive has a project they care about. It's also the fastest way to win back belief. When people watch leadership remove something honestly and fund what's left, the next plan stops starting at a discount.
That only works if the executive team goes first. Leaders who protect their own favorite project while asking every department to justify theirs teach the company that the rules are for other people. Everyone below them is watching which projects survive the review.
Where Trifecta Comes In
At Trifecta, this is where much of our work starts. We sit down with the executive team, read the budget as the strategy it really is, and close the gap between what the company says it wants and what it's paying for. We name the constraint, blueprint the fix, and install it with your team until they own it.
Our operator note, What Are You Willing To Stop Doing?, makes every new request name the constraint it fixes before it gets a dollar. This piece covers the other direction: the priorities leadership announced that never got a request, a line or a person at all. Run both, and what you say and what you pay for start to match.
The Question for Your Next Leadership Meeting
Southwest's pilots read the budget for years before the rest of the country did. Your newest hire read yours in a week.
So read it yourself before they read the next one. Which of your stated priorities has no money behind it?
If that question makes the room go quiet, your team already knows the answer. Let's talk. Book 30 minutes.
Sources
Dollars & Sense, "Stop Stock Buybacks!," May/June 2023: Southwest announced reinstatement of its quarterly dividend on December 7, 2022; nearly 17,000 flights cancelled December 20 to 29, about 2 million passengers stranded; SWAPA president Casey Murray's Senate testimony that pilots had warned about crew scheduling technology for years, and his November 7, 2022 "one thunderstorm, one air traffic control event, one IT router failure away" remark. https://www.dollarsandsense.org/stop-stock-buybacks/
CNN (via ABC7), "Southwest hit by record $140M fine for holiday service meltdown in 2022," December 18, 2023: meltdown cost nearly $1.2 billion; unions blamed antiquated scheduling technology; executives admitted the scheduling system was a problem at a congressional hearing. https://abc7news.com/southwest-airlines-fined-meltdown-fine/14197362/
Comments